Pick Pay Drive Car Rentals

Unwind on beautiful beaches, town, coastal village, restaurants, and many island attractions with comfortable rides available with Pick Pay Drive Car Rentals. Whether it’s Sapphire Blue Hole, Glass Widow Bridge, pink sand beaches, Island tour, and airport transfer. Pick Pay Drive Car Rentals provide private, spacious, and affordable car rental service to explore beautiful Eleuthera, Bahamas.We provide free pick up and delivery to North Eleuthera Airport or any location in North Eleuthera.

Cars We Have

Our vehicles are cheapest on the Island. We are an Affordable and Reliable Car Rental Company. Book us today for all your car rental needs

$75/Day

$450/Week

$1600/Month

$75/Day

$450/Week

$1600/Month

$80/Day

$500/Week

$1800/Month

$110/Day

$700/Week

$2500/Month

$120/Day

$800/Week

$2800/Month

$80/Day

$500/Week

$1800/Month

$110/Day

$700/Week

$2500/Month

$110/Day

$700/Week

$2500/Month

$/Day

$/Week

$/Month

$110/Day

$700/Week

$2500/Month

$110/Day

$700/Week

$2500/Month

$120/Day

$800/Week

$2800/Month

$120/Day

$800/Week

$2800/Month

Why to Choose Pick Pay Drive Car Rentals

Testimonials

SEE WHAT OUR CUSTOMERS SAY

David Able

Great communicator!

We just returned from Eleuthera and rented a car for 10 days from Pick Pay Drive (Cordero Johnson). Great communicator who stayed in close contact with us along our entire journey. Met us at the airport to pick up our car which was clean and in great working order, and we were able to drop it back at the airport on our way out making it super convenient for us.Highly recommend, will use again!

Verified Customer

Evy daemon

Really great place!

Really great place to rent a car to see the beautiful beaches and places on Eleuthera!
Thanks a lot for the early pickup directly at the office!

Verified Customer

Steve No

Great experience!

Great experience! I arrived from the United States and was met immediately at the airport with my car. They were always very responsive and texted me quickly. The car was great. Excellent service!

Verified Customer

Lisa dauphinais

I really love there service

I really love there service and they are very reliable. They are also quick to respond though email or text. They also provide help if you have any issues during your rental. Thanks again
Lisa

Verified Customer

T 9

Excellent

Very happy with the little car.
It was The most comfortable of all the 3 rental cars we had during our stay on Eluthera.
Good on gas mileage,  got around 42+ miles to the gallon.
Easy to drive. Easy to rent. Will use Pick and Pay first next time.

Verified Customer

Chris Young

Great!

I had several email exchanges with Cordero, who was very prompt, clear, and helpful in all our communications -- if we return to the island in the future, we'll definitely start by seeking him out first.

Verified Customer

Sharnette Kemp

Quick, efficient service, very accommodating and affordable pricing. Vehicles like new.

Verified Customer

MY

wow

Would rent again.

Verified Customer

Hunter Genovese

Great experience!

Very good communication and flexibility! Great car and experience!

Verified Customer

Lola Maijian

Highly recommend!

I highly recommend! Nardo took great care of us, it's square and when the bridge was closed because of the storm, he picked us up at the exit of the boat to drop us off at the airport 🤗

Verified Customer

Michael Wade

Highly Recommend!

Verified Customer

Natalya Ash

Excellent Service!

Verified Customer

Chrystal Cooper

Would definately rent from you guys again! Professional Service!!!

Verified Customer

Christopher Neely

The best car rental agency in Eleuthera!

Verified Customer

Christine Johnson

Never disappoints. My go to place for a car rental

Verified Customer

Lanardo Johnson

Very professional and affordable car rental company!

Verified Customer

Chris Simmons

We rented for 16 days in February. PickPay was great. We were met at N. Eleuthera airport. The car was parked nearby. We rented a Nissan Note which was fine for all the paved and unpaved roads we encountered, though clearly not an SUV for really rough tracks. The car ran fine and we returned it to its original parking space near the airport. All communications with PickPay were easy. We would definitely use PP again.

Verified Customer

Mark Donevant

Highly Recommend

Great rental company, fast service, great communication. Highly recommend, plus right there at ELH

Verified Customer

K Carroll

Easy Process!

Could not have been easier to rent from Pick Pay! Less $ than other companies. We were met at the airport, car was clean and easy to drive. NO problem driving in Eleuthera — roads are wide and easy to navigate.

Verified Customer